God's Exhaustive Foreknowledge

Clete

Truth Smacker
Silver Subscriber
The point that time does not exist in the way Einstein described needs to be pounded home. It is just a way to express duration. He says of himself "God waits", ending the debate and point.
Sorry for the length of this post! I didn't set out to write something this extensive, but you happen to hit on one of my favorite topics! :cool:


Time does exist in the way Einstein described it. The point is to understand what he meant when he described it.

Einstein said that "time is what clocks measure," and he meant that in such a way that if whatever you're doing affects the clocks around you, then whatever you're doing is affecting time itself. From a practical standpoint, Einstein was right. His theory has been confirmed thousands of times in dozens of different ways, not the least of which is every time you use Google Maps to get from one place to another. The GPS system has to account for the effects of relativity on its clocks in order to provide accurate positioning information. In short, if every physical process around you is proceeding more slowly or more quickly than the corresponding processes experienced by someone else, then for all practical purposes, time is passing at a different rate for you than it is for them.

Insisting that Einstein was wrong is the equivalent of putting one's head in the sand. It is far better to define our terms and recognize that we're talking about two different, although closely related, concepts. Time, in the sense we're using it in our philosophical and theological discussions, is not defined in terms of clocks (at least not explicitly), nor is it something that exists independently as an aspect of the physical universe. Rather than existing in an ontological sense, it is an idea, an abstraction. Time is the concept we use to communicate information about the sequence and duration of events relative to other events.

Notice, however, how closely the two concepts overlap. What exactly does a clock measure? A clock doesn't measure some independently existing substance called time. It measures one physical process against another. A pendulum clock counts the oscillations of a pendulum. A mechanical clock counts the movements of its internal mechanism. An atomic clock counts oscillations associated with transitions between atomic energy states. In every case, we're taking a regular sequence of physical events and using it as a standard against which to measure the sequence and duration of other events. In other words, a clock is simply a physical device that uses numbers to communicate information about the sequence and duration of events relative to other events. That's essentially the same thing we're doing when we talk about time in the philosophical sense.

The distinction becomes even more interesting when we consider what Einstein actually demonstrated. According to relativity, clocks operating under different physical conditions can accumulate different amounts of elapsed time. A clock traveling at high speed relative to another clock, or operating in a different gravitational environment, can register a different amount of elapsed time when the two are compared. This has been experimentally confirmed countless times. What is particularly interesting is that the effect isn't limited to clocks. The physical processes themselves are involved. Atomic oscillations, chemical reactions, biological processes and everything else that occurs within a particular physical system are subject to the same relativistic relationships.

The point there being, that if every physical process occurring around you were affected in precisely the same way, how would you know that anything had changed? Your clock would continue ticking normally. Your heart would continue beating normally. Chemical reactions would proceed normally. Every physical process you could use to measure another physical process would remain in perfect agreement with it. From your own perspective, nothing would be different. The difference becomes apparent only when you compare those processes with the corresponding processes occurring under different physical conditions.

This is precisely where Einstein's conception of time and the philosophical conception we're defending intersect. Both involve describing relationships between events. The physicist uses clocks and mathematical equations to quantify those relationships, while the philosopher uses the concept of time to identify and discuss them. Einstein's equations can be entirely correct without establishing that time exists as an independent entity. They describe real, measurable relationships between physical events. Whether those relationships require the existence of some additional thing called "time" is an entirely different question. Indeed, the very fact that clocks measure physical processes relative to other physical processes illustrates why the distinction matters. We can measure the duration of an event without supposing that duration is itself some independently existing thing.

There is, however, another, more fundamental issue that really demonstrates the difference between what Einstein meant by time and what we mean by it. It has to do with the nature of the present. Everything that happens, happens presently. Every event that has ever occurred happened in the present, and every event that ever will occur will happen in the present. The past and the future are not actual collections of events sitting somewhere out of sight. They are abstractions. They are the concepts we use to organize our experience. The past is what we remember or infer from present evidence; the future is what we anticipate. Neither is a place or a destination, and nothing ever travels from one to the other. All that actually exists is the present, and everything that happens necessarily happens in it.

This is where Bob Enyart's Summit Clock experiment becomes particularly illuminating. Imagine two perfectly functioning atomic clocks, one at the summit of a mountain and the other at its base. Because of gravitational effects, the summit clock runs slightly faster. Allow the experiment to continue long enough, and the clocks will eventually disagree by a day, a year, or even hundreds of years. Yet throughout the entire experiment, both clocks have existed in the present. Neither clock has traveled into the future relative to the other. Every tick of both clocks occurred presently. Every sunrise, every sunset, and every other event that occurred during the experiment also occurred presently. Both clocks, the observers, the mountain, the Earth, and the sun all began the experiment together in a single present moment, existed together throughout its entire duration, and ended the experiment together in that same shared present. When the clocks are finally brought back side by side, they will display different readings, one having accumulated vastly more oscillations than the other, but neither has ever experienced a single event outside the present.

Consider what would happen if the difference between the clocks were allowed to accumulate to something substantial, say 500 years. One clock would indicate that 500 more years had passed than the other. Yet both clocks would have existed through exactly the same sequence of sunrises, sunsets, seasons and historical events. Neither clock would have witnessed an event that hadn't yet happened for the other. If we introduced a third reference, such as the Earth's rotation, both observers could objectively agree about how many days had passed according to that standard. The clocks might disagree about the amount of elapsed time they had recorded, but neither clock could change the sequence of events that had actually occurred.

This is the point that I think gets lost when physicists and philosophers discuss time. Relativity describes how physical processes behave under different physical conditions and how those processes can be measured relative to one another. It provides extraordinarily accurate mathematical descriptions of those relationships. What it does not establish is that the present itself passes at different rates or that anything can somehow leave the present and arrive in the future. Indeed, what would it even mean to leave the present? Any such departure would itself have to occur presently, as would the supposed arrival. The very concept seems incoherent. Nothing ever leaves the present because there is nowhere else for anything to exist.

Even the disagreements that arise from relativity concerning the simultaneity of distant events do nothing to change this fundamental fact. Two observers may disagree about whether distant events occurred simultaneously, but their observations, measurements and disagreements all occur presently. Whatever conclusions they reach about the relationships between those events, neither observer has ever experienced anything except the present. Their disagreement about how to describe the events doesn't somehow cause either observer to escape it.

The present does not move through time. Events occur, and our concepts of past, present and future describe their relationship to one another. The fundamental reality is the occurrence of events. Time is the abstraction by which we describe their succession and duration, and clocks are physical devices by which we measure those relationships. Everything that happens, happens presently, and that remains true regardless of what any clock happens to say.

This also brings us back to the theological point. When Scripture tells us that God waits, acts, responds or changes His mind, it is describing a sequence of events involving God. One thing happens, then another. There is no need to suppose that God exists within some independently existing substance or dimension called time in order for those statements to be meaningful. God experiences succession because He acts, thinks and responds. The events themselves are real, and their sequence is real. Time is simply the abstraction we use to describe that reality.

Einstein's theory doesn't threaten that understanding in the slightest. Properly understood, it provides a fascinating illustration of just how closely our measurements of time are connected to the physical events by which we measure it. We can acknowledge everything Einstein demonstrated about the behavior of clocks and physical processes without accepting that time is some independently existing thing through which the universe, or God Himself, must somehow travel. The present is where reality happens, and nothing, including God, ever exists anywhere else.

Now, (see what I did there!), there's one last major point to discuss which has to do with space. Just as time is an abstraction by which we describe the sequence and duration of events relative to other events, so space is an abstraction by which we describe the position and size of objects relative to other objects. If space and time are both abstractions describing relationships between physical realities, their mathematical interdependence becomes considerably less mysterious because we're describing two aspects of the relationships between things and events. Nearly everything that has been said here about time and its relationship to clocks can be said with equal force about space and its relationship to rulers. Einstein combined the two into one thing which he called "Spacetime". The point being that "Spacetime" may be an extraordinarily accurate mathematical description of the relationships between physical objects and events without being an independently existing thing in its own right.

So in the end, we don't have to choose between Einstein's physics and the biblical picture of God. When we recognize that space, time, and spacetime are concepts we use to describe real relationships between real things and events, the whole tension disappears. Einstein gave us the mathematical tools to measure how physical processes behave relative to one another, while philosophy and theology remind us that reality itself always happens right now, in the present. God doesn't need a cosmic stopwatch or a fourth dimension in order to act, respond, or wait. He simply does those things, one real event after another, and time is just our way of talking about it.
 
Last edited:

way 2 go

Well-known member
No, read the scriptures. He has a contingent plan, but you seem to be an idolator having your own version of God in your mind.
says the guy with his own version of God ,
open theist have a God that doesn't know the present exhaustively and
doesn't know foreknow the future at all (◔_◔)

(Acts 15:18) All His works are known to God from eternity.
not a contingency plan
7 The instant I speak concerning a nation and concerning a kingdom, to pluck up, to pull down, and to destroy it, 8 if that nation against whom I have spoken turns from its evil, I will relent of the disaster that I thought to bring upon it.

(Revelation of John 4:1) After these things I looked, and behold, a door was opened in Heaven. And the first voice which I heard was as it were of a trumpet talking with me, saying, Come up here, and I will show you what must occur after these things.

God foreknows
(Revelation of John 9:15) And the four angels were loosed, who were prepared for an hour, and a day, and a month, and a year, in order to slay the third part of men

did not repent
Revelation 9:20
Revelation 9:21
Revelation 16:9
Revelation 16:11
 

way 2 go

Well-known member
Did God have to have exhaustive infallible foreknowledge of you, every detail about you, every decision you make, thought that you have, before He could create the heavens and the earth?

Yes or no?
(Acts 15:18) All His works are known to God from eternity.
(Psalms 139:2) You know my sitting down and my rising up; You understand my thought afar off
(Psalms 139:7) Where shall I go from Your Spirit? Or where shall I flee from Your presence
got nothing
No, it doesn't.
yes it does
Not what scripture says.

God establishes His intention to make Adam a suitable helper BEFORE He brings the animals to him. (verse 18)

And notice what the verse says: "TO SEE WHAT HE WOULD CALL THEM."

The verse DOES NOT read like God already knew what Adam would call the animals.

God didn't need exhaustive, infallible foreknowledge of Adam's decisions to know what He intended to accomplish.
so?

its not the proof text you think it is
God asks for information he already knows
example:
(Matthew 22:19-21) [19] Show Me the tribute money. And they brought a denarius to Him. [20] And He said to them, Whose image and inscription is this? [21] They said to Him, Caesar's. Then He said to them, Therefore render to Caesar the things that are Caesar's, and to God the things which are God's.



And why does Scripture say God brought the animals before Adam "to see what he would call them"?
looking for a help mate
(Genesis 2:20) And Adam gave names to all the cattle, and to the birds of the air, and to every animal of the field. But there was not found a suitable helper for Adam.
First of all, Abraham didn't sacrifice Isaac. God stopped him when he reached out and took the knife.
no , but there is that Jesus foreshadowing thing
Second, it's not necessary for God to know "[H]e would provide the ram in the thicket , from eternity."
the ram in the thicket ... God did know , its one of his works that he knew beforehand
(Acts 15:18) All His works are known to God from eternity.
Abraham's journey took him into the third day before he reached the place God had appointed. (This is also a striking foreshadowing of Christ's death and resurrection. Isaac, Abraham's "only begotten son" (Hebrews 11:17), though not his firstborn, was the unique son of promise. Abraham was prepared to sacrifice him, and on the third day received him back, figuratively speaking, from the dead (Hebrews 11:19). Isaac was spared because God provided a substitute. Christ, God's only begotten Son, actually died and rose again on the third day, because He Himself IS our Substitute. And none of what transpired later needed to be eternally infallibly foreknown for God to use this event in Abraham's life as typology for Christ's yet-future crucifixion.)

That's more than enough time for God to observe Abraham's conduct, consider his thoughts and intentions, and arrange for a ram to be caught in the thicket to be available as a substitute should Abraham follow through.

Nor would God have needed to wait until the last moment to prepare a substitute. He could have made provision for either possible outcome.

He doesn't need an eternity to do those things.

And what did God say when Abraham demonstrated his obedience?

"NOW I KNOW that you fear God." (Genesis 22:12)
(Matthew 25:21) His lord said to him, Well done, you good and faithful servant: you have been faithful over a few things, I will make you ruler over many things: enter you into the joy of your lord.

not a revelation to God

You keep insisting that God already knew the result from eternity, while the passage explicitly records God declaring what He now knows following the test.

He's far more capable than you make Him out to be. Don't belittle God.
confession through projection
Begging the question.

You're simply assuming that these passages describe works God foreknew from eternity.

Some of them don't even describe works of God!

Acts 8:1 describes SAUL'S actions, not God's.
God allowed Saul to kill Stephen
Proverbs 3:11–12 and Hebrews 12:5–6 concern God's correction of those He loves.
Correction is intended to change someone's course of action. But if God already infallibly knows every future human choice, then, given that fixed knowledge, there is no genuinely open alternative course for anyone to take.

So what genuinely possible alternative course of action remains available to the person being corrected, given God's supposedly fixed, infallible prior knowledge?
when did God know of those works of course correction ?
you guessed it , from eternity

"from the beginning of the world" and "from eternity" doesn't really matter , still foreknowleddge

what does God know ? all his works
when did God know all his works ? "from the beginning of the world" and "from eternity"
therefore foreknowledge of all his works
Acts 15:18 Known to God from eternity are all His works.

Proverbs 11:21 states a general principle concerning the wicked and the righteous.

Other passages describe God's character, His intentions, or His responses to human conduct.

And those that actually describe God's works don't say that God knew those particular works from eternity.

You're reading your conclusion into these passages rather than deriving it from them.

That's eisegesis.

And you still haven't demonstrated that God's knowledge of His own works requires exhaustive, infallible foreknowledge of every future human choice.


why the move of
established that God possesses exhaustive, infallible foreknowledge
to
requires exhaustive, infallible foreknowledge



this verse tells when God knew and what God knew , not my opinion.
Acts 15:18 Known to God from eternity are all His works.

what God knew from eternity which necessitates exhaustive, infallible foreknowledge
(Ephesians 2:10) For we are his workmanship, created in Christ Jesus to good works, which God has before ordained that we should walk in them.
 

JudgeRightly

裁判官が正しく判断する
Staff member
Administrator
Super Moderator
Gold Subscriber
@way 2 go, how about we make a deal. You give me your best, and I mean your absolute best single prooftext for God's "exhaustive infallible foreknowledge," and if I demonstrate that the verse is not teaching what you claim when taken at face value, in other words, I show you from the context of the verse that it's teaching something other than "exhaustive infallible foreknowledge," if I can do that, then we can safely dismiss any other prooftexts you might bring or have brought as teaching your position, because if your absolute best prooftext verse doesn't teach it, then there's zero chance that the rest of them will.

And if I can't show that it means something other than EIF, based on the context, then I will give up Open Theism entirely, and start teaching that God has EIF.

How about it?

Give it your best shot.

What is your best single prooftext (verse or passage) for God having exhaustive infallible foreknowledge of all future human choices?

And don't be quoting multiple verses from different parts of the Bible, just one single verse or passage that you think is the absolute best prooftext for your position.

says the guy with his own version of God ,
open theist have a God that doesn't know the present exhaustively

Yes. And?

Until you establish that God needs to have all present knowledge, then there's no reason for it to be a problem for us to think that He doesn't.

and
doesn't know foreknow the future at all (◔_◔)

False.

God knows what He has determined to accomplish and can foresee future events based upon His knowledge of present circumstances.

What we're disputing is your claim that He infallibly knows EVERY future human choice.

Stop conflating specific foreknowledge with exhaustive foreknowledge.

(Acts 15:18) All His works are known to God from eternity.
not a contingency plan

Supra.

(Revelation of John 4:1) After these things I looked, and behold, a door was opened in Heaven. And the first voice which I heard was as it were of a trumpet talking with me, saying, Come up here, and I will show you what must occur after these things.

God foreknows
(Revelation of John 9:15) And the four angels were loosed, who were prepared for an hour, and a day, and a month, and a year, in order to slay the third part of men

did not repent
Revelation 9:20
Revelation 9:21
Revelation 16:9
Revelation 16:11

Supra. See posts #54, #60, and #64.

Foreknowledge of particular future events does not establish exhaustive foreknowledge of EVERY future human decision.

(Acts 15:18) All His works are known to God from eternity.
(Psalms 139:2) You know my sitting down and my rising up; You understand my thought afar off
(Psalms 139:7) Where shall I go from Your Spirit? Or where shall I flee from Your presence

Answer the question.

Did God have to have exhaustive infallible foreknowledge of you, every detail about you, every decision you make, thought that you have, before He could create the heavens and the earth, yes or no?

got nothing

False.

Supra.

yes it does

No, it doesn't.


So God had already declared His intention to provide Adam with a helper before Adam named the animals.

Knowing what He intended to accomplish didn't require knowing beforehand what Adam would name them.

its not the proof text you think it is
God asks for information he already knows
example:
(Matthew 22:19-21) [19] Show Me the tribute money. And they brought a denarius to Him. [20] And He said to them, Whose image and inscription is this? [21] They said to Him, Caesar's. Then He said to them, Therefore render to Caesar the things that are Caesar's, and to God the things which are God's.

And?

Jesus asked a question about something that already existed, using their answer to teach them a lesson.

Genesis 2:19 says God brought the animals to Adam "TO SEE WHAT HE WOULD CALL THEM."

That's a statement about something Adam had not yet done.

You haven't demonstrated that God already infallibly knew what Adam would call them.

looking for a help mate
(Genesis 2:20) And Adam gave names to all the cattle, and to the birds of the air, and to every animal of the field. But there was not found a suitable helper for Adam.

You're ignoring verses 18-19.

Stop ripping verses out of context.

And the LORD God said, “It is not good that man should be alone; I will make him a helper comparable to him. ” Out of the ground the LORD God formed every beast of the field and every bird of the air, and brought them to Adam to see what he would call them. And whatever Adam called each living creature, that was its name. So Adam gave names to all cattle, to the birds of the air, and to every beast of the field. But for Adam there was not found a helper comparable to him.
https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Genesis 2:18-20&version=NKJV

God had already declared His intention to provide Adam with a suitable helper. But the stated purpose of bringing the animals before Adam was "to see what he would call them."

Those are two distinct statements, and neither requires God to have infallibly known Adam's future decisions.

no , but there is that Jesus foreshadowing thing

the ram in the thicket ... God did know , its one of his works that he knew beforehand

Again, your assumption is not required by the text. You still need to demonstrate that your belief is required.

Nothing in Genesis 22 establishes that God infallibly knew from eternity that He would provide that particular ram.

Nor does the foreshadowing of Christ's sacrifice establish exhaustive, infallible foreknowledge.

(Acts 15:18) All His works are known to God from eternity.

Supra.

(Matthew 25:21) His lord said to him, Well done, you good and faithful servant: you have been faithful over a few things, I will make you ruler over many things: enter you into the joy of your lord.

not a revelation to God

Matthew 25:21 is a parable in which a master commends his servant for his faithfulness.

Genesis 22:12 is God declaring, "NOW I KNOW that you fear God."

The master in Matthew 25 doesn't say "now I know."

You're comparing two statements that say different things and assuming they must mean the same thing.

confession through projection

Bearing false witness is a sin, w2g.

God allowed Saul to kill Stephen

First, Acts 8:1 says Saul CONSENTED to Stephen's death. It doesn't say Saul personally killed him.

Second, permitting something isn't the same as performing it.

Saul's sinful conduct wasn't God's work.

when did God know of those works of course correction ?
you guessed it , from eternity

"from the beginning of the world" and "from eternity" doesn't really matter , still foreknowleddge

Another assertion.

Even if God infallibly knew He would perform a particular act of correction, that wouldn't establish exhaustive foreknowledge of every human choice.

And you still haven't answered my question about what genuinely open alternatives remain available to someone receiving that correction, given your supposedly fixed, infallible foreknowledge.

what does God know ? all his works
when did God know all his works ? "from the beginning of the world" and "from eternity"
therefore foreknowledge of all his works
Acts 15:18 Known to God from eternity are all His works.

You're confusing knowledge of God's works since the beginning with foreknowledge of those works before they occurred.

"From the beginning of the world" does not mean "before the beginning of the world," nor does it necessarily mean "before those works occurred."

God knows all His works since the beginning, including those He began long ago and continues to accomplish. In other words, He hasn't forgotten His works, His promises, or His purposes concerning Israel and the Gentiles. That's what the verse is saying.

That's consistent with the immediate context of Acts 15:13–19. James is explaining God's dealings with the Gentiles in light of His historical dealings with Israel.

Nothing in that context requires the interpretation you're imposing upon the verse.

And even if I granted your interpretation that God foreknew every one of His own future works, you STILL haven't demonstrated that this requires exhaustive, infallible foreknowledge of every future human choice.
HIS works are not OUR works.

You're still assuming the very thing you're supposed to prove.

why the move of
established that God possesses exhaustive, infallible foreknowledge
to
requires exhaustive, infallible foreknowledge

There is no move.

The question is whether Scripture establishes that God possesses exhaustive, infallible foreknowledge.

YOU introduced the assertion that God HAS TO KNOW every future human choice in order to know His own works.

I'm challenging that claimed necessity because it's the premise upon which your interpretation depends.

You've never demonstrated it.

this verse tells when God knew and what God knew , not my opinion.
Acts 15:18 Known to God from eternity are all His works.

Supra.

what God knew from eternity which necessitates exhaustive, infallible foreknowledge
(Ephesians 2:10) For we are his workmanship, created in Christ Jesus to good works, which God has before ordained that we should walk in them.

And?

God prepared good works beforehand for those who are in Christ to walk in.

The passage doesn't say that God infallibly knew every future decision those believers would make.

Nor does it establish that those good works require exhaustive knowledge of every human choice.

You're once again confusing God's preparation of what He intends people to do with infallible foreknowledge of everything they actually will do.

That's not what the verse teaches.

And let's not forget you haven't answered my challenge in post #73.

What is your single strongest prooftext for God's exhaustive, infallible foreknowledge of every future human choice?

Just one.

Surely you can identify your strongest scriptural evidence for a doctrine you're so certain the Bible teaches.
 
Top