Should Women Be Beaten?

[intojoy]

Once when I was young, my girlfriend at the time whiz zed a coffee cup by my head!
I took the plastic radio clock and tossed it at her (underhand toss) she ducked down an it hit the top of her head. She had to get stitches (2). People, we make mistakes. The funny thing is that she told the hospital I punched her. Then later she called me to pick her up. Man. That girl was nuts! I was too tho

 

[resurrected]

Absolutely none.

how would you react if you walked in to your wife beating your child?

let's assume that she doesn't stop when you say "honey, stop doing that"

are you justified in using physical force to stop her?

 

[intojoy]

how would you react if you walked in to your wife beating your child?



let's assume that she doesn't stop when you say "honey, stop doing that"



are you justified in using physical force to stop her?

Yes. She might need a lil shock therapy

 

[intojoy]

Hey what happened to deplorestare

 

[resurrected]

he earned himself a vacation


but he'll be back

 

[Spitfire]

This is getting really boring.

I had a great idea for a variation of this thread. Just remove one letter. But most of the people here would not be mature enough to handle the topic.

 

[intojoy]

he earned himself a vacation





but he'll be back

Hope ain't takin this out on the mrs

 

[CabinetMaker]

how would you react if you walked in to your wife beating your child?

let's assume that she doesn't stop when you say "honey, stop doing that"

are you justified in using physical force to stop her?

There is rather a difference between physically restraining her and punching her. Or shoving her.

 

[intojoy]

This is getting really boring.

I had a great idea for a variation of this thread. Just remove one letter. But most of the people here would not be mature enough to handle the topic.

Heathen

 

[staind.raindrop]

There is rather a difference between physically restraining her and punching her. Or shoving her.

You speak as though you have experience? If not, you should restrain your mouth.

 

[intojoy]

There is rather a difference between physically restraining her and punching her. Or shoving her.

My wife beat the crap outta me the other day.

She's I'm a man and she's a woman so it don't count

 

[intojoy]

My wife beat the crap outta me the other day.

She's I'm a man and she's a woman so it don't count

Why? You might ask?
....I told her she skipped a week

 

[resurrected]

This is getting really boring.

I had a great idea for a variation of this thread. Just remove one letter. But most of the people here would not be mature enough to handle the topic.

perhaps we could hire some cannibals

There is rather a difference between physically restraining her and punching her. Or shoving her.

not according to rusha and angel

it's all abuse

 

[CabinetMaker]

perhaps we could hire some cannibals



not according to rusha and angel

it's all abuse

I rather doubt that Rusha and A4T would see restraint to prevent somebody from beating their child as abuse.

 

[CabinetMaker]

You speak as though you have experience? If not, you should restrain your mouth.

No direct experience. Why would that render my opinion invalid?

 

[CabinetMaker]

My wife beat the crap outta me the other day.

She's I'm a man and she's a woman so it don't count

Sounds like there may be bigger issues in your relationship. In any case, and at the risk of being grossly misunderstood, you do have the right to defend yourself if somebody is attacking you. In my mind, defending yourself is not abuse, it is defense.

 

[staind.raindrop]

@CM

It rarely works and you'd know that if you were in the position, that's why.

 

[resurrected]

I rather doubt that Rusha and A4T would see restraint to prevent somebody from beating their child as abuse.

if it was a woman forcefully stopping a man?

i agree


if it was a man forcefully stopping a woman? :idunno:

 

[Angel4Truth]

if it was a woman forcefully stopping a man?

i agree


if it was a man forcefully stopping a woman? :idunno:

Whose lying now? :think:

 

[CabinetMaker]

@CM

It rarely works and you'd know that if you were in the position, that's why.

I heard terrible yelling one day and went to investigate. I found my wife and two daughters in a very loud argument over something really silly, don't even recall what. I looked at all three of them and sent them all to their rooms. Seriously. They all went and after about 15 minutes, everybody was calm and the whole thing is over. I fail to see why physically restraining somebody would be any less effective. Sometimes you need to get people out of the immediate situation to let them regain their control and then you can deal with the issue.