ARCHIVE: I believe religion to be obsolete

Granite

New member
Hall of Fame
Brandon, you need to really stop taking yourself so seriously.

You work at a DAIRY QUEEN, for crying out loud.
 

Granite

New member
Hall of Fame
:chuckle:

Sorry, couldn't help myself.

Only so often I get to take potshots at a Comic Book Crusader for Christ...
 

Jackielabby

Banned
Banned
Religion is slowly, ever so slowly becoming obsolete in the UK, thank Man. The number of Church of England baptisms here is going down year by year. From 151,400 in 2002 to 144,300 in 2003. The number in 2001 was 153,300. I for one, am happy that we are becoming more and more secular.
 

Rolf Ernst

New member
Granite--the catholic church in italy is also home base of the Jesuites and the Black Pope. Have you cared enough about accuracy in your judgements to even check out the website about "Vatican Asassins"?

The fault in your argument is that you are--deliberately I believe-- condemning reaL christians by identifying them with many who have in the past associated themselves with christendom as a means of achieving ungodly ends. The Black Pope and the Jesuits are a large element and factor with which you seemingly want to link real christians and condemn them together. Stalin was a Jesuit, and your desire, I believe, is to condemn all christians together with him when, in reality, Stalin's attitude toward people of faith was very much like yours. Your attitude is very much like the attitude of both Hitler and Stalin. Accordingly, you have very noiticeably ignored murder in the name of secular, atrheistic socialism while daring to attempt to go back centuries to place some blame on the church.

You have never stopped trying to defame Christians, and you think I should chill out to placate YOU???
 

Granite

New member
Hall of Fame
Originally posted by Rolf Ernst

Granite--the catholic church in italy is also home base of the Jesuites and the Black Pope. Have you cared enough about accuracy in your judgements to even check out the website about "Vatican Asassins"?

The fault in your argument is that you are--deliberately I believe-- condemning reaL christians by identifying them with many who have in the past associated themselves with christendom as a means of achieving ungodly ends. The Black Pope and the Jesuits are a large element and factor with which you seemingly want to link real christians and condemn them together. Stalin was a Jesuit, and your desire, I believe, is to condemn all christians together with him when, in reality, Stalin's attitude toward people of faith was very much like yours. Your attitude is very much like the attitude of both Hitler and Stalin. Accordingly, you have very noiticeably ignored murder in the name of secular, atrheistic socialism while daring to attempt to go back centuries to place some blame on the church.

You have never stopped trying to defame Christians, and you think I should chill out to placate YOU???

The Black Pope theory is so much papal paranoia, as far as I'm concerned. Off in the la-la land of Jack Chick.

Comparing me to Hitler or Stalin is almost too grotesque to merit a response...
 

Rolf Ernst

New member
Why?? All three of you hold attacks against Christ in common. Just acknowledge who your compatriots are. The things you say on this forum are in line with what the enemies of the truth have said through the ages. Openly take your place beside them.
 

Rolf Ernst

New member
Granite--wishfully saying something is just "papal paranoia" from
"la la land"won't make it go away. You have never researched the matter or else you would not be denying the reality.

With the internet at our fingertips, failure to do just a little research
makes us blameworthy.
 

Granite

New member
Hall of Fame
Originally posted by Rolf Ernst

Why?? All three of you hold attacks against Christ in common. Just acknowledge who your compatriots are. The things you say on this forum are in line with what the enemies of the truth have said through the ages. Openly take your place beside them.

Jefferson, Paine, Voltaire, and other skeptics have all attacked the fables of Christianity too, genius. Hitler praised the church and cowed it into submission--Stalin did the same thing. Comparing me to the man who murdered some of my ancestors is offensive in the extreme.

Rolf, here's what you don't get: I'm not opposed to people going to church, practicing Christianity, whatever. If it works for you, fine; knock yourself out. The last thing I want is to see people rounded up and killed for their faith. I don't think you see the difference between critiquing Christianity and wanting Christians dead. It's hyperbole, it's a ridiculous stretch, and you know it. Grow up.
 

Granite

New member
Hall of Fame
Originally posted by Rolf Ernst

Granite--wishfully saying something is just "papal paranoia" from
"la la land"won't make it go away. You have never researched the matter or else you would not be denying the reality.

With the internet at our fingertips, failure to do just a little research
makes us blameworthy.

Rolf: I have researched the so-called Black Pope and what have you. I don't find the theory very convincing. Remember, people have the right to disagree with you and your conclusions. Just an FYI.:rolleyes:

You never did name the commentators who agreed with your scripture twisting, which you guaranteed you'd do...:think:
 

cleo

New member
Originally posted by Rolf Ernst

Stalin was a Jesuit
Stalin was never a Jesuit (i.e., a member of the Roman Catholic Society of Jesus). He studied at the Georgian Orthodox (an entirely different religion) seminary in what is now Tblisi, the capital of the Georgian republic, but was expelled at the age of 19. There is a lot of spurious anti-Catholic conspiracy theory out there on the internet. Since pretty much everything I have posted here on tautology-on-line so far has been distorted, I will add that I am not Catholic, but I don't like to see them maligned or misrepresented.
Here's a little more on the subject:
http://www.straightdope.com/columns/020614.html
 

Jackielabby

Banned
Banned
I am with you on this Cleo. I used to be a catholic and resent the anti-catholic comments regularly posted on this site. A bit KKKish sometimes. But then the KKK is a christian organisation, isn't it?
 
Last edited:

Lighthouse

The Dark Knight
Gold Subscriber
Hall of Fame
Jackie-
You said that you gave up on Christianity because of something you saw a priest do. So why would you resent anti-Catholic comments?:rolleyes:

You're a terrible liar.:nono:
 

jjjg

BANNED
Banned
Granite, that whole bit about the church being in league with Hitler has been debunked on threads here a long time ago and Hitler was so in league with Catholics then why did he kill millions of Catholic Poles?
 

Granite

New member
Hall of Fame
Originally posted by jjjg

Granite, that whole bit about the church being in league with Hitler has been debunked on threads here a long time ago and Hitler was so in league with Catholics then why did he kill millions of Catholic Poles?

He didn't kill millions of Catholic Poles. The lion's share of murdered Poles happened to be Jewish (no surprise).

I didn't say the church was in league with Hitler, that I recall. Some supported the Reich, some didn't. It was certainly in their interest to toe the line...again, no surprise.

I really wish you people would pay attention and quit jumping the gun.
 

jjjg

BANNED
Banned
http://isurvived.org/2MemorialDrives/4_PolishVictims.html

Read the article as well as hundreds of others on the Internet.

Three million Catholic poles killed in the Holocaust. You're not a holocaust denial supporter are you?

By the way, Granite, the Black Pope refers to the head Jesuit in Rome not some Papal conspiracy theory.

Learn about a topic before you start yapping away.
 
Top