wickwoman
New member
Clete in the thread started by Stunrut: “Is Speeding a Sin?” had some very detailed information on what sort of speeding the Bible allows or disallows. Though cars were not yet invented or even conceived of at the time, it seems people like Clete have no problem conveniently justifying their small, non-moral violation of rules they so vehemently insist that everyone else follow. Here’s Clete’s opinion on speeding:
And here is my response to a post of Clete’s a little further along in the thread:
What was the wonderful response of the verbose Clete the ultimate “truthsmacker?”
Nothing, zilch, nada.
Congratulations Clete!You get Wickwoman's Dodge of the Day! :first:
Clete said:The law does not say, Thou shalt not speed.
It says that if you are caught speeding then police officer who witnessed it can decide whether or not to stop you. He then must decide whether or not to fine you. Then if the judge or prosecutor decides it is in the best interest of the community to lower that fine in order to save the tax payer the expense of a trial he has the authority to do that and whatever that final agreed upon amount is, you can pay right then or they will usually give you as much as an additional 30 days to pay it; it just depends on how broke you tell the judge you are at the moment. And the important point is that as long as you pay it, the authorities simply don't care about how fast you drive. If they did, it wouldn't be up to the discretion of the officer, the prosecutor or the judge as to whether or not you were properly punished for the "crime". And note that this whole time the one who pays the fine has remained completely within the law of the land.
The point here is that speeding laws are arbitrary and they have more to do with revenue for the city or state than anything else. The proof of this is the fact that it is almost universally true that you simply will not be fined or probably even pulled over for doing anything less than 10 mph over the posted speed limit. They don't do it because it cost the city more money to process the payment of your fine than the amount of the fine can cover. As long as you aren't going crazy weaving all over the road and being dangerous, it's not worth their time or effort to stop you. In some cases, city planners actually take this into consideration when deciding what the posted speed limit should be. They intentionally set it lower than they actually expect for the traffic to go! And once again, this can happen because the law states that the fine is triggered at the discretion of the police officer not at the breaking of the speed limit.
So all that to say this: I detect no hint of guilt or of wrong doing at all when I travel at speeds less than 10 mph over the posted speed limit as long as I am not acting as if the road belongs to me and that I'm the only one who exists on the street. If your conscience is clear then there is no sin in your doing the same. However, if you violate your conscience you sin, whether the act itself is actually wrong or not so be careful to examine yourself and then do as God would have you do.
Clete said:Well there is no 10 mph rule, nor is there a 5 mph rule. It's all entirely up to the cop who caught you. It's arbitrary is the point. As long as you are willing to pay the fine if you get one, then breaking such arbitrary rules is not a moral issue.
And here is my response to a post of Clete’s a little further along in the thread:
Clete said:All of them that we can. I am not suggesting that we can ignore the speed limit but only that we should keep in mind the context in which the law is passed and enforced. The laws are not intended to keep you from going past 75 mph (in Oklahoma).
Wickwoman said:Can you point us to the Oklahoma Code section that discusses this grace speed of 5-10 mph over? Strange that they just didn't go ahead and make the speed limit 10 mph higher.
Clete said:If that were the intent I can guarrantee you that they could make it happen. There are dozens of ways which they could make certain that you do not exceed the posted speed limit. They could install id tags in the state lisence plates that track your location and time you from one point to another and if you've get there too fast it pops out a speeding ticket in the mail. They could require the police to pull over anyone that they ever see doing even 1 mph over the speed limit and fine them $100.00 for ever mile an hour over the limit they were caught driving at. Mechanical failure is no excuse, it should be the responsibility of the driver to maintain his car in propper working order so that the laws of the land will be followed. And there are dozens of other creative ways the government to see to it that you do what they want you to do. But the point is that there is no need for such things.
Wickwoman said:Or :idea: maybe, just maybe they are busy spending money on crime control and other issues that are more harmful and, though they do want you to follow the laws they don't have the money or manpower to go to this extent.
In fact, every time a law enforcement officer sets up a speed trap to catch speeders, she/he is being taken away from an urban crime area. And the more people that speed, the more officers are needed for speed control. As a result, the police departments nationwide are underfunded and overworked on average. And the reason they don't go after the 5-10 mph over people is just that they lack the manpower and the money.
Clete said:The fact that this it is even a question whether disobeying the speed limit is a sin is proof by itself that it isn't.
Wickwoman said:Actually, what it's more proof of, Clete, is that some Christians often conveniently ignore the "simple sins" because its inconvenient to be obedient when it comes to being kind or obeying the speed limit, or showing love to others. However, they are more than happy to point out the "big sin" to those they consider sinners.
What was the wonderful response of the verbose Clete the ultimate “truthsmacker?”
Nothing, zilch, nada.
Congratulations Clete!You get Wickwoman's Dodge of the Day! :first:
Last edited: