Pro-Gays, is incest immoral?

[glassjester]

A question for people that do not believe homosexuality is immoral, or intrinsically disordered.

Do you believe incest is morally wrong? Why/why not?

Additionally, do you believe bans on incestuous marriage are unconstitutional, and incestuous couples should be allowed to marry? Why/why not?

 

[The Horn]

Glassjester , how the heck can you compare homosexuality to incest ? You're just rehashing the same old tired conservative theocratic excuses for demonizing gay people and denying them rights .
Consensual sex between gays in private does NOT harm anyone else. Bestiality, incest, pedophilia, etc are dangerous and harmful behavior , much of it caused by mental illness . Pedophilia is a mental illness. Being a homosexual is NOT .
Children born of incest are at serious risk of severe genetic problems, physical disorders and disabilities etc .

 

[glassjester]

Children born of incest are at serious risk of severe genetic problems, physical disorders and disabilities etc .

Oh, so now sex is just for having children? Puritan!

 

[ok doser]

Children born of incest are at serious risk of severe genetic problems, physical disorders and disabilities etc .

so you're fine with incest as long as there's no children produced?

 

[glassjester]

May I assume then, The Horn, that you would be all for homosexual incestuous marriage?

 

[glassjester]

so you're fine with incest as long as there's no children produced?

He will not answer, because this question proves the slippery slope is real.

MrDante, in another thread, has shown this.
He has defended homosexuality.
He has now admitted to being pro-incest.

As he is unable to defend one, without the other.
Yet, The Horn, and many others insist there is no connection between incest and homosexuality.

We're just flying down that slippery slope!

 

[glassjester]

Children born of incest are at serious risk of severe genetic problems, physical disorders and disabilities etc .

Besides, if the incest baby is deformed, the couple can just get an abortion!

 

[aCultureWarrior]

Consensual sex between gays in private does NOT harm anyone else...

And harm it does cause to those who engage in homosexuality.

I never thought I'd see that day that one of my favorite sexual anarchists on TOL would become a theocrat.

You do realize that if you outlaw incest, bestiality and other sexual perversions, that would make us a theocracy don't you De Horn? (and everyone hates a theocracy)

 

[glassjester]

You do realize that if you outlaw incest, bestiality and other sexual perversions, that would make us a theocracy don't you De Horn? (and everyone hates a theocracy)

And allowing such perversions is simply the logical consequence of supporting homosexuality.

Yet, people such as The Horn, with feigned ignorance, continue to ask, "How can you compare homosexuality to incest?"

 

[glassjester]

The invitation stands.

Can any pro-gay folks explain if and why incest is immoral, or if and why they support incestuous marriage?

 

[Tambora]

Some good questions in here.

 

[glassjester]

Some good questions in here.

Too bad no one will answer them.

 

[annabenedetti]

The invitation stands.

Can any pro-gay folks explain if and why incest is immoral, or if and why they support incestuous marriage?

Why are you comparing the two when they're not comparable?

Although I'm curious as to what you think: was it immoral when it happened in the Old Testament?

 

[Nick M]

Bestiality, incest, pedophilia, etc are dangerous and harmful behavior , much of it caused by mental illness .

What makes you think it is mental illness?

 

[Nick M]

Ryan White disagrees with those who say faggotry does not harm anybody else.

 

[aCultureWarrior]

Quote Originally Posted by glassjester

The invitation stands.

Can any pro-gay folks explain if and why incest is immoral, or if and why they support incestuous marriage?

Why are you comparing the two when they're not comparable?

Surely you're not denying that there are homosexual incestuous relationships are you anna?

Incestuous twin brothers wonder if they should reveal their secret ...
http://www.slate.com/articles/life/...should_reveal_their_secret_relationship_.html

Two brothers sodomizing so quietly that no one would ever know...

 

[quip]

A question for people that do not believe homosexuality is immoral, or intrinsically disordered.

Do you believe incest is morally wrong? Why/why not?

Additionally, do you believe bans on incestuous marriage are unconstitutional, and incestuous couples should be allowed to marry? Why/why not?

First, bridge that logical gap...your delicate moral sensibilities make for an impassable crossover for the rest of us.

 

[glassjester]

What makes you think it is mental illness?

That's a good question, too.

 

[glassjester]

Why are you comparing the two when they're not comparable?

Although I'm curious as to what you think: was it immoral when it happened in the Old Testament?

First, bridge that logical gap...your delicate moral sensibilities make for an impassable crossover for the rest of us.

Just can't bring yourself to answer?


Come on, be a sport.

Do you think incest is immoral?
Do you think incestuous marriage should be legal?

 

[annabenedetti]

Just can't bring yourself to answer?

I'll answer. I have questions first.