Home
Forums
New posts
Search forums
What's new
New posts
New profile posts
Latest activity
Members
Current visitors
New profile posts
Search profile posts
Log in
Register
What's new
Search
Search
Search titles only
By:
Current visitors
New profile posts
Search profile posts
Menu
Log in
Register
Install the app
Install
Forums
Members
JavaScript is disabled. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an
alternative browser
.
MWinther's latest activity
MWinther
replied to the thread
Progressive Disenchantment Atonement
.
I am not proposing the reconstruction of a magisterium. I am simply identifying the causes that led to the spread of Protestant...
Apr 30, 2026
MWinther
replied to the thread
Progressive Disenchantment Atonement
.
When literalist Christians tell me to just open the Bible and read it, as if the truth were simply written there in black and white, I...
Apr 30, 2026
MWinther
replied to the thread
Progressive Disenchantment Atonement
.
In fact, I am criticizing the concept of "a list of doctrines one must believe in order to be truly saved as a Christian," which has...
Apr 29, 2026
MWinther
replied to the thread
Progressive Disenchantment Atonement
.
Oh yes, many have done that and theologians have criticized this reduction of divinity. Fabien Muller argues that modern theology often...
Apr 29, 2026
MWinther
replied to the thread
Progressive Disenchantment Atonement
.
...
Apr 29, 2026
MWinther
replied to the thread
Progressive Disenchantment Atonement
.
The divine cannot be reduced to a set of doctrines. Barth is right to warn that Christians often try to construct a ladder of...
Apr 29, 2026
MWinther
replied to the thread
Progressive Disenchantment Atonement
.
Karl Barth (CD I/2 §17) maintains that human beings continually construct conceptual and ritual "ladders" to heaven. Whenever we place...
Apr 28, 2026
MWinther
replied to the thread
Progressive Disenchantment Atonement
.
You keep returning to the idea that faith means believing that God exists. But that is not faith. In fact, it is through faith that God...
Apr 28, 2026
MWinther
replied to the thread
Progressive Disenchantment Atonement
.
Instead of climbing a ladder of good deeds, one climbs a ladder of correct ideas. But the ladder is the same. The pride is the same, and...
Apr 28, 2026
MWinther
replied to the thread
Progressive Disenchantment Atonement
.
Some Christians mistakenly translate faith into "believing the right doctrines." But biblically, faith is not assent to a list of...
Apr 28, 2026
MWinther
replied to the thread
Progressive Disenchantment Atonement
.
That is incorrect. When I reference Herrick, for example, it is because I recently read his book. I also cite his work in a recent...
Apr 26, 2026
MWinther
replied to the thread
Progressive Disenchantment Atonement
.
The theological framework of my interlocutors appears to share significant structural similarities with Islam, particularly in its...
Apr 26, 2026
MWinther
replied to the thread
Progressive Disenchantment Atonement
.
The Church Fathers, including Paul, employed participatory language to describe heavenly life. Paul specifically framed this reality...
Apr 26, 2026
MWinther
replied to the thread
Progressive Disenchantment Atonement
.
This is double‑predestination rhetoric pushed to its extreme, turning pastoral doctrine into speculative philosophy. For Luther, the...
Apr 26, 2026
MWinther
replied to the thread
Progressive Disenchantment Atonement
.
Paul is speaking here about moral conduct. As the Reformers made clear, this does not bring us any closer to God. That view is...
Apr 25, 2026
Forums
Members
Top