ECT What makes Preterism so impossible

Sonnet

New member
It wasn't a "good number", it was the vast majority including the High Priest, the Pharisees, and the Sadducees.



Yes



Christ Jesus told the Jews they were a brood of vipers, that they were an evil generation, and that their father was Satan.

The Apostle Paul said the Jews were "hostile to everyone".

What part don't you understand?

Do you consider it justifiable to dislike Jews because of the reasons you have stated?
 

john w

New member
Hall of Fame
"The Apostle Paul was the biggest anti-Semite there ever was..."-satanist Craigie Tellalie
 

Totton Linnet

New member
Silver Subscriber
Wrong.

When Jesus told them: "When you see these things happen, keep your eyes open, because you'll know the time is near", they didn't think Jesus was talking about some Jews 2,000 (and still counting) years into the future who had made their way back into Palestine.

The Jews Jesus was speaking to, knew it meant THEM.

Actually He DID know He was speaking far into the future and He told parables to the effect that they should not expect His return any time soon

After He was risen and taught them the kingdom they asked about the re-establishment of the kingdom and Jesus told them clearly that this was not for them, their job was to witness "to the ends of the earth"


.....that would not be done anytime soon

Also the apostles predicted the coming of false prophets after their demise
 

Totton Linnet

New member
Silver Subscriber
The TEMPLE was destroyed and with it the religion and so the religious leaders, and they were the ruling class...and THEY are the only ones who were warned to flee from the wrath to come, those who opposed Christ and the apostles

Why don't you open your eyes and SEE?

The multitude flocked to Jesus, the common people heard Him gladly, after Pentecost they flocked to the apostles thousands being saved every day.

The Jews were not destroyed they were dispersed, they have been laid aside, but God is going to take them up again...that is why they are being gathered.

True theology doesn't have any jagged stickee out bits, no contradictions.

If you find contradictions it is because your theology is wrong.

interplanner might have missed this one
 

tetelestai

LIFETIME MEMBER
LIFETIME MEMBER
So you are asserting that we ARE to treat Jews with disdain are you?

Nope.

Do you call Muslim's "God's chosen people"?

Do you call Buddhist's "God's chosen people"?

If not, why would you call Christ rejecting Jews "God's chosen people"?
 

tetelestai

LIFETIME MEMBER
LIFETIME MEMBER
Actually He DID know He was speaking far into the future and He told parables to the effect that they should not expect His return any time soon

No such parable says what you claim.

After He was risen and taught them the kingdom they asked about the re-establishment of the kingdom and Jesus told them clearly that this was not for them, their job was to witness "to the ends of the earth"

(Matt 10:23) Truly I tell you, you will not finish going through the towns of Israel before the Son of Man comes.

.....that would not be done anytime soon

It was done before 70AD

Also the apostles predicted the coming of false prophets after their demise

Already happened.

Josepus tells about many false prophets that came before the Rebellion in 66AD.
 

tetelestai

LIFETIME MEMBER
LIFETIME MEMBER
"The Apostle Paul was the biggest anti-Semite there ever was..."-satanist Craigie Tellalie

(Gal 3:7) Understand, then, that those who have faith are children of Abraham.

The Israel of God are those who have faith in Christ Jesus.

The "real" children of Abraham are those who have faith in Christ Jesus.
 

tetelestai

LIFETIME MEMBER
LIFETIME MEMBER
Do you consider it justifiable to dislike Jews because of the reasons you have stated?

There are two kinds of people in the world A) Believer's in Christ B) non-believers.

The Jews are non-believers. Not only are they non-believers who reject Christ Jesus, they follow an evil book (The Talmud) which says Jesus was a bastard child who practiced sorcery and black magic, that Jesus was sexually immoral, and that His mother Mary was a whore.

The Talmud also says Jesus is in hell, being boiled in "hot excrement."

Jews today are enemies of the gospel. They are no different than Muslim's, Buddhist's, Atheist's, Hindi's, or any other Christ rejecting people.
 

Interplanner

Well-known member
No such parable says what you claim.



(Matt 10:23) Truly I tell you, you will not finish going through the towns of Israel before the Son of Man comes.



It was done before 70AD



Already happened.

Josepus tells about many false prophets that came before the Rebellion in 66AD.



On the topic of a distant return, there is the 4 options of Mark 13. But that would be in the category of worldwide judgement, not 1st century Judea. Once again, Mt24A and B cannot be mixed, even if some exhortations about being ready read the same. It is total confusion if they are mixed. He is either speaking about 1st century Judea or about the worldwide coming in judgement.
 

Interplanner

Well-known member
Actually He DID know He was speaking far into the future and He told parables to the effect that they should not expect His return any time soon

After He was risen and taught them the kingdom they asked about the re-establishment of the kingdom and Jesus told them clearly that this was not for them, their job was to witness "to the ends of the earth"



Mk 13's parable does allow for a distant return, but you must be aware that Paul never mentions this allowance. The coming in judgement is immediately after the catastrophe in Judea. I know of no place where he thinks the 2nd coming in judgement is distant.


.....that would not be done anytime soon

Also the apostles predicted the coming of false prophets after their demise



Mk 13's parable does allow for a distant return, but you must be aware that Paul never mentions this allowance. The coming in judgement is immediately after the catastrophe in Judea. I know of no place where he thinks the 2nd coming in judgement is distant.
 

tetelestai

LIFETIME MEMBER
LIFETIME MEMBER
Once again, Mt24A and B cannot be mixed, even if some exhortations about being ready read the same.

(Matt 24:34) Truly I tell you, this generation will certainly not pass away until all these things have happened.

Everything (all these things) before verse 34 did happen by 70AD.
 

Interplanner

Well-known member
interplanner might have missed this one


lol, no contradictions!

There were lower and middle classes who wanted him to be king (Jn 6--the objectors being the ruling class), and then wanted others proposed by the zealots to be king/messiah. He ministered in Galilee a lot which was not ruling class, because there were many forceful zealots there. The negative references to Galileans found in the gospel accounts is not because they are hicks but because the ruling class is concerned about their inflammatory nature.

On the question of Judaism,
God does not have two programs going and never really did. There is a reason why Gal 3:17 presumes what it does about Judaism. Since the 1900s Jews have wanted to be in their own land, but the question we are concerned with as Christian representatives is whether the letter to Hebrews is to be reversed. It is not.

on the question of ethne groups,
You must have missed the end of Rom 11, in which all 'dealings' with ethnes are canceled. God deals with all mankind, or not, through Christ. The previous is over; it is quite possibly a misconception any, says Gal 3:17. Promises are fulfilled, and binding over to sin, are both in relation to Christ, nothing else.

re contradictions
D'ism is one after another. Mt 24A and B cannot be mixed without contradiction. Matt 24A is about 1st century Judea. B is about the worldwide coming in judgement which is delayed (it could have been right away). The ethical exhortations of each section may be the same but not the locations or times.
 

Interplanner

Well-known member
(Matt 24:34) Truly I tell you, this generation will certainly not pass away until all these things have happened.

Everything (all these things) before verse 34 did happen by 70AD.


That's right, except for the one he could not say, that only the Father knows, at that point.
 

tetelestai

LIFETIME MEMBER
LIFETIME MEMBER
That's right, except for the one he could not say, that only the Father knows, at that point.

"not knowing the day or hour" is a reference to the Feast of Trumpets.

Christ Jesus' return was the fulfillment of the three fall feasts, beginning with the Feast of Trumpets.

If you study the seven feasts, the Feast of Trumpets is the only feast that begins on a new moon, all the other feasts occur during full moons.

The Sanhedrin would send out two witnesses to look for the new moon. When the two witnesses saw the new moon, they would come back, tell the Sanhedrin, and then the trumpets would blow to commence the feast.

Sometimes, it was two or three days before the two witnesses would see the new moon. Therefore, "no one knew the day or hour" when the feast would begin.
 

tetelestai

LIFETIME MEMBER
LIFETIME MEMBER
Then you have to support 70AD as a worldwide day of judgement. Go ahead.

Was Luke 2:1 worldwide?

(Luke 2:1) And it came to pass in those days, that there went out a decree from Caesar Augustus that all the world should be taxed.

Did the Mayan's in Central America pay taxes to Caesar Augustus?
 

Sonnet

New member
There are two kinds of people in the world A) Believer's in Christ B) non-believers.

The Jews are non-believers. Not only are they non-believers who reject Christ Jesus, they follow an evil book (The Talmud) which says Jesus was a bastard child who practiced sorcery and black magic, that Jesus was sexually immoral, and that His mother Mary was a whore.

The Talmud also says Jesus is in hell, being boiled in "hot excrement."

Jews today are enemies of the gospel. They are no different than Muslim's, Buddhist's, Atheist's, Hindi's, or any other Christ rejecting people.

'Jews are believers' is as valid as your statement that, 'the Jews are non-believers'.

Why are you focusing on the Jew's rejection of Christ when it's a fact that Gentiles do too?
 
Top