toldailytopic: Once a person is saved can they reject that salvation should they chan

Grosnick Marowbe

New member
Hall of Fame
Thanks, GM. I'm always amazed how people think everyone is saved in every letter to the churches just because it's written in the Bible.... and so everything stated therein must apply to the saved. When Paul addresses the letter to the church in Corinth, for example. Or 1 John....Jason thinks even those in darkness are saved and need to move back into the light. No wonder there's so much confusion around here. :chuckle:

Mostly, it's the proverbial, blind leading the blind syndrome!
 

godrulz

Well-known member
Hall of Fame
It boils down to this; most on this thread believe in a "works based religion" on the other hand, a very few (perhaps only two) believe that Christs shed blood and resurrection took away ALL their sins, and they have been placed into the body of Christ, by the work of the Holy Spirit, and cannot lose their standing before God!
Why you may ask? Because, Christ is in us and we are in Christ!!

It is a Calvinistic myth that Arminian faith is a work or that perseverance/continuing in the faith is a work.

This just shows how little you understand the academic debate.

Unbelief is a unique sin that is not forgiven before or after conversion. If someone persists in Christ rejecting, godless unbelief/rebellion, they do not have assurance of eternal life if they die in that state (otherwise you are saying someone can be saved apart from Christ). If someone can rebel before conversion, why cannot they use the same mind/will to rebel/reject after conversion? Sure, believers are secure, but one may not remain a believer unto death. A change in status has consequences.
 

godrulz

Well-known member
Hall of Fame
It really boils down to this: Some people cannot tell the difference between conversion and salvation. Because of that, they refuse to listen to those that can.

Conversion/salvation are usually interchangeable.

Not telling the difference between justification, sanctification, perseverance, glorification is a problem.
 

Grosnick Marowbe

New member
Hall of Fame
The Jews were apostate when they neglected so great a salvation. For some reason, you think a born again believer can be an apostate which shows you are failing to see who, exactly, is being spoken of in any given verse. Remember, the Jews were God's chosen people. When the Gospel was preached to them, many failed to ENTER IN to the faith. Therefore, their rejection of the Messiah made them turn their back on the one true God.

That's why it's so important to rightly divide the word and pay close attention to the context in which something is being spoken, and to who it pertains to!
 

godrulz

Well-known member
Hall of Fame
The Jews were apostate when they neglected so great a salvation. For some reason, you think a born again believer can be an apostate which shows you are failing to see who, exactly, is being spoken of in any given verse. Remember, the Jews were God's chosen people. When the Gospel was preached to them, many failed to ENTER IN to the faith. Therefore, their rejection of the Messiah made them turn their back on the one true God.

A Jew who never became a Christian is not an apostate. In Islam, an apostate is someone who leaves Islam for something else. By definition, a Christian apostate is someone who leaves Christianity for x, y, z, not someone (Jew, atheist, Muslim, JW, Hindu, etc.) who never was a Christian. You don't fall away from truth if you never had it.

A false convert, a non-convert, etc. is not an apostate, but a generic non-Christian unbeliever. Hebrews is talking about Jewish Christians who reverted back to Judaism and no longer trusted Christ and His finished work. It is not just talking about Jews who never converted (that is another problem). Fakes who never were converted, but call themselves Christians (Mormons, nominal, liberal religionists, etc.), are not apostates, but non-Christians.
 

Grosnick Marowbe

New member
Hall of Fame
Will you listen to these supposed scholars? Not I, says GM! Besides myself, there's only one other on this thread (at this time) who knows what they're talking about! The others, don't have a clue!
 

glorydaz

Well-known member
A Jew who never became a Christian is not an apostate. In Islam, an apostate is someone who leaves Islam for something else. By definition, a Christian apostate is someone who leaves Christianity for x, y, z, not someone (Jew, atheist, Muslim, JW, Hindu, etc.) who never was a Christian. You don't fall away from truth if you never had it.

A false convert, a non-convert, etc. is not an apostate, but a generic non-Christian unbeliever. Hebrews is talking about Jewish Christians who reverted back to Judaism and no longer trusted Christ and His finished work. It is not just talking about Jews who never converted (that is another problem). Fakes who never were converted, but call themselves Christians (Mormons, nominal, liberal religionists, etc.), are not apostates, but non-Christians.

Of course that's your opinion. Whenever you read about loss of a former belief in the Bible, you think it means a falling away from the Christian faith, but the Jews believed in God and you seem to forget that. I don't give a hoot about muslims and what they believe. I'm talking about the Bible and how you assume certain verses refer to a loss of salvation....such as you do when you cite Hebrews.
 

Grosnick Marowbe

New member
Hall of Fame
I am a he.

I keep forgetting what your background and beliefs are. I assume you affirm the trinity?

You are probably non-church going (unbiblical) or independent sect.

Do you have any atypical beliefs, besides OSAS?

Gods forgiveness, mercy and eternal life is given to those who place their faith in Christ as Lord and Savior! One must first hear the word,
from the word of God, they must be convinced they're a sinner and confess such to God! Once true faith has been established, the Holy
Spirit cleanses the sins of the new believer, seals them, indwells them
and places them into the Body of Christ! They're now, in Christ and Christ is in them! They are positioned into Christ and therefore, that positioning makes them sinless before God. However, they still have a physical (fleshly) body that is capable of disobedience towards God, and God reserves the right to discipline His children, and does!

There is no condemnation/judgment that awaits the true believer, only the gain or loss of rewards in eternity! The flesh still is susceptible to sin but, the spirit of the believer is positioned so, they do not and cannot sin!
 

glorydaz

Well-known member
Gods forgiveness, mercy and eternal life is given to those who place their faith in Christ as Lord and Savior! One must first hear the word,
from the word of God, they must be convinced they're a sinner and confess such to God! Once true faith has been established, the Holy
Spirit cleanses the sins of the new believer, seals them, indwells them
and places them into the Body of Christ! They're now, in Christ and Christ is in them! They are positioned into Christ and therefore, that positioning makes them sinless before God. However, they still have a physical (fleshly) body that is capable of disobedience towards God, and God reserves the right to discipline His children, and does!

There is no condemnation/judgment that awaits the true believer, only the gain or loss of rewards in eternity! The flesh still is susceptible to sin but, the spirit of the believer is positioned so, they do not and cannot sin!

Now there's the simple Truth without a bunch of tomfoolery. :thumb:
 

glorydaz

Well-known member
Then why are we warned to stay the course?
Why are we warned to not shrink back?
Why are we warned to make sure we produce good fruit?
None of this would be required IF OSAS was a reality.

Things Children of God Can Do:
1. Fall from grace - Gal. 5:1-4,13
2. Be led away with error - 2 Pet. 3:17
3. Err from the truth - James 5:19-20
4. Weak brother may perish - 1 Cor. 8:11
5. Fall into condemnation - James 5:12
6. Be moved away from the hope - Col. 1:21-23
7. Deny the Lord who bought them - 2 Pet. 2:1
8. Depart from the living God - Heb. 3:12
9. Can be a castaway - 1 Cor. 9:27
10. Can become accursed children - 2 Pet. 2:14

What about Rev 2:4-5, 3:5 & 16-17?





I'd be more than happy to take each one of the verses on one at a time, if you really want to know what they are saying. But the statement in yellow is a perfect example. We don't produce fruit. The fruit is the Spirit's and He produces it in us. We are His Workmanship...not our own. If you try to manufacture meekness and gentleness you'll end up sounding like Jason...it's fake. To be real, it can't come from ourselves.
 

Grosnick Marowbe

New member
Hall of Fame
I'd be more than happy to take each one of the verses on one at a time, if you really want to know what they are saying. But the statement in yellow is a perfect example. We don't produce fruit. The fruit is the Spirit's and He produces it in us. We are His Workmanship...not our own. If you try to manufacture meekness and gentleness you'll end up sounding like Jason...it's fake. To be real, it can't come from ourselves.

Great truth
 
Top