ok doser
lifeguard at the cement pond
he can speak for himself, but i didn't see that he was using them as inseparably linked, just attributes that might be pertinent to the topic of euthanasia
Canada to initiate Project Soylent
- Thread starter musterion
- Start date
he can speak for himself, but i didn't see that he was using them as inseparably linked, just attributes that might be pertinent to the topic of euthanasia
Those were the terms him and AB agreed upon for this particular argument and ones that jester subsequently ran with. AB's only error was in following along with this line of bunk.
It's the logic of jester's straw-man that's pertinent here not the definition of "terminally ill".
ok doser
lifeguard at the cement pond
ok doser
lifeguard at the cement pond
link?
ok doser
lifeguard at the cement pond
looks like artie's the one who said "both":
ok doser
lifeguard at the cement pond
:doh: he had them split up before artie said both
He knows AB's argument on the matter from prior conversations (this thread and others). That's precisely why jester laid it out like he did.
You know this...don't be disingenuous.
ok doser
lifeguard at the cement pond
GJ asks:
artie waffles all over the place and throws the occasional hissyfit, referencing pain, suffering and imminence of death
GJ patiently asks again:
artie composes himself and replies:
GJ respectfully asks:
artie responds (without defining his terms):
and GJ attempts to determine the particular quality that allows euthanasia:
i don't see how you could "infer that [GJ's] definition of a terminally ill individual (like Art's) is one where said individual endures both pain and has limited time left to live."
i see it as GJ allowing artie to set the parameters and then trying to understand what he's said: "yes""no""i don't know" "hissyfit"
but again, it would be easy enough to ask him :idunno:
artie waffles all over the place and throws the occasional hissyfit, referencing pain, suffering and imminence of death
GJ patiently asks again:
artie composes himself and replies:
GJ respectfully asks:
artie responds (without defining his terms):
and GJ attempts to determine the particular quality that allows euthanasia:
i don't see how you could "infer that [GJ's] definition of a terminally ill individual (like Art's) is one where said individual endures both pain and has limited time left to live."
i see it as GJ allowing artie to set the parameters and then trying to understand what he's said: "yes""no""i don't know" "hissyfit"
but again, it would be easy enough to ask him :idunno:
Last edited:
ok doser
lifeguard at the cement pond
back to this:
what I infer from that exchange is that GJ was using artie's unspecified (and flawed, as I have shown) "definition"
but you are certainly free to infer whatever you like :idunno:
what I infer from that exchange is that GJ was using artie's unspecified (and flawed, as I have shown) "definition"
but you are certainly free to infer whatever you like :idunno:
:chuckle:
That movie managed to be comedic, dramatic, and terrifying all at once.
Good stuff.
ok doser
lifeguard at the cement pond
i didn't really start to like it until I found a subtitled version
I wanted to get subtitles to that movie 'The Revenant' because of those long scenes with the Natives talking.
It's ridiculously graphic and gritty. You feel the bruises in that movie just like Braveheart or The Passion.
Arthur Brain
Well-known member
Pretty much sums it up and I've hardly been unclear on my position whenever this subjects come up.
:e4e:
Arthur Brain
Well-known member
C'mon Quip, this is SOD you're talking with, you expect the guy to be 'genuine'?! :shocked:
Guys had more bans and usernames than any other poster on this forum. Right now he's smarting because he's not getting any traction from the posters he's obsessed with, especially TH. So he wastes his time trolling on threads hoping to get a reaction. It doesn't seem to have registered with the nut that folk are just bored of his tired little shtick so have him on ignore.
Still, his time to waste.
ok doser
lifeguard at the cement pond
wow - what a boring, predictable whiner :yawn:
ok doser
lifeguard at the cement pond
then explain this:
| GJ: Then if either of those aspects is missing, they do not have the right to suicide? AB: Yes |
or were you drinking?
glassjester
Well-known member
Hello, Quip.
Here's a question for you:
Is there anyone who you think should not be given the right to end his own life?